Elon Musk has sturdy views on hydrogen. Not everybody agrees

A automobile is fueled with hydrogen on the Frankfurt Auto Present IAA in Frankfurt am Most important, Germany, on September 13, 2017.


Tesla CEO Elon Musk has a historical past of expressing sturdy opinions about hydrogen and hydrogen gasoline cells.

Just a few years in the past, when the topic got here up throughout a dialogue with reporters on the Automotive Information World Congress, the billionaire and electrical automobile magnate described hydrogen gasoline cells as “extraordinarily foolish.”

“It is simply very tough … to make hydrogen and retailer it and use it in a automobile,” Musk mentioned. “The most effective-case hydrogen gasoline cell does not win towards the present case batteries, so then, clearly … it does not make sense,” he added later.

“That can grow to be obvious within the subsequent few years. There’s … no purpose for us to have this debate, I’ve mentioned … my piece on this, it will likely be tremendous apparent as time goes by, I do not know what extra to say.”

Within the time since these remarks, Musk’s views do not appear to have modified a lot, if in any respect. In June 2020 he tweeted “gasoline cells = idiot sells,”  including in July of that 12 months: “hydrogen idiot sells make no sense.”

The tech

First issues first: What underpins the tech Musk appears so skeptical of?

The U.S. Environmental Safety Company describes hydrogen gasoline cell automobiles — that are also called gasoline cell electrical automobiles — as being “much like electrical automobiles … in that they use an electrical motor as an alternative of an inner combustion engine to energy the wheels.”

The important thing distinction is that electrical automobiles have batteries that must be charged by plugging the automobile right into a charging level. Gas cell automobiles, then again, make the most of hydrogen gasoline and, in keeping with the EPA, “generate their electrical energy onboard.”

Learn extra about electrical automobiles from CNBC Professional

Put merely, with gasoline cells, hydrogen gasoline from a tank mixes with oxygen, producing electrical energy.

A gasoline cell electrical automobile emits “solely water vapor and heat air”, the U.S. Division of Power’s Various Fuels Knowledge Heart says.

A variety of views

Musk isn’t alone with regards to being unconvinced about using hydrogen in vehicles.

In February of this 12 months, Herbert Diess, the CEO of German automotive powerhouse Volkswagen Group, weighed in on the topic.

“It is time for politicians to just accept science,” he tweeted. “Inexperienced hydrogen is required for metal, chemical, aero … and mustn’t find yourself in vehicles. Far too costly, inefficient, sluggish and tough to rollout and transport. In spite of everything: no #hydrogen vehicles in sight.”

Musk and Diess are two high-profile figures on the helm of main corporations with big affect and attain. What they are saying carries weight. It will seem, nonetheless, that their views aren’t shared by everybody within the autos sector.

To this point, corporations together with Toyota and Hyundai have produced hydrogen gasoline cell automobiles, whereas smaller producers resembling Riversimple are additionally engaged on hydrogen-powered vehicles.

In June, the BMW Group mentioned it had began to check automobiles that use a hydrogen gasoline cell drivetrain, with the corporate describing hydrogen gasoline cell tech as having the “long run potential to complement inner combustion engines, plug-in hybrid methods and battery-electric automobiles.”

Though these merchandise clearly do not account for the majority of automobile gross sales at this second in time — Riversimple will not really promote its vehicles, providing them on a subscription service as an alternative — that such a variety of corporations are engaged on fuel-cell choices in any respect exhibits some see potential within the expertise.

“Gas cell vehicles will definitely play an element in decarbonizing transport,” a spokesperson for Toyota advised CNBC.

“As and when refueling infrastructure expands, they’ll provide a handy various type of electrified transport over a completely electrical BEV [battery-powered electric vehicles],” they mentioned.

Toyota considered hydrogen “as an alternative choice to fossil fuels in all method of settings, together with heating, lighting, haulage, mass transit and heavy trade,” the spokesperson mentioned.

“The vary of hydrogen purposes will improve, enabling cheaper, extra environment friendly energy provide and we’ll more and more see hydrogen powering vehicles, buses, trains and vans,” they added.

In an announcement despatched to CNBC, the Gas Cell and Hydrogen Power Affiliation expressed an analogous viewpoint.

Gas cell electrical automobiles and hydrogen power, the FCHEA mentioned, supplied prospects “a zero-emission possibility with efficiency they anticipate and no change to each day routines — lengthy vary, fast refueling, and the power to scale to bigger platforms with out including restrictive weight and dimension.”

The FCHEA went on to say there was a “super alternative for gasoline cell electrical vehicles and gasoline cell-powered materials dealing with automobiles.”  

“Additionally, given the constraints of battery weight and recharging for lengthy haul trucking, a major alternative additionally exists for medium- and heavy-duty supply vans, vans, buses, trains, and planes,” it mentioned.

Certainly, as governments world wide try to develop low and 0 emission transportation methods, the notion of utilizing hydrogen gasoline cells in bigger automobiles is beginning to be explored by a broad vary of corporations.

Learn extra about clear power from CNBC Professional

In a current interview with CNBC, the CEO of Daimler Truck was requested in regards to the debate between battery-electric and hydrogen gasoline cells. Steadiness, Martin Daum argued, was key.

“We go for each, as a result of each … make sense,” he mentioned, occurring to clarify how completely different applied sciences could be applicable in several eventualities.

“Usually, you possibly can say: For those who go to metropolis supply the place you want decrease quantities of power in there, you possibly can cost in a single day in a depot, then it is definitely battery electrical,” Daum mentioned.

“However the second you are on the highway, the second you go from Stockholm to Barcelona … in my view, you want one thing which you’ll be able to transport higher and the place you possibly can refuel higher and that’s finally H2.”

“The ruling isn’t out, however I feel it is too dangerous for an organization our dimension to go along with only one expertise.”


Daum’s feedback on gasoline cells contact upon the concept that they may, ultimately, discover a residence in heavier types of transport overlaying lengthy distances, hauling cargo and, in some instances, ferrying individuals from one vacation spot to a different.

He isn’t alone in taking this view. The European transport big Alstom, for example, has developed the Coradia iLint, which it describes as “the world’s first passenger prepare powered by a hydrogen gasoline cell.”

In aviation, plans to function business hydrogen-electric flights between London and Rotterdam have been introduced in October, with these behind the undertaking hoping it’ll take to the skies in 2024.

In building, JCB, a serious participant within the sector, mentioned final 12 months that it had developed an excavator “powered by a hydrogen gasoline cell.”

Weighing 20 metric tons, the corporate mentioned the automobile had been examined for over 12 months, including that the “solely emission from the exhaust is water.”


Whereas there’s a sense of pleasure about using hydrogen gasoline cell expertise in quite a lot of purposes, the trail to any mass rollout might not essentially be a easy one.

Earlier this 12 months, Honda ceased manufacturing of its Readability plug-in hybrid and gasoline cell fashions, though the corporate did make a degree of claiming that gasoline cell electrical automobiles would “play a key function in our zero-emissions technique.”

Elsewhere, the U.S. authorities has cited numerous challenges. These vary from the sturdiness and reliability of gasoline cells to automobile price.

“The present infrastructure for producing and getting hydrogen to shoppers can’t but help the widespread adoption of FCVs,” it provides.

In February 2020, Brussels-based marketing campaign group Transport and Setting hammered residence simply how a lot competitors hydrogen would face within the transportation sector.

T&E made the purpose that inexperienced hydrogen — which is produced utilizing renewables — would not solely should “compete with gray and blue hydrogen,” that are produced utilizing fossil fuels. “It’s going to compete with petrol, diesel, marine gasoline oil, kerosene and, in fact, electrical energy,” T&E mentioned.

“Wherever batteries are a sensible resolution — vehicles; vans; city, regional and maybe long-haul vans; ferries — hydrogen will face an uphill wrestle due to its decrease effectivity and, consequently, a lot greater gasoline prices.”

Bridging the hole between battery electrical and gasoline cell automobiles can be an enormous process, because the Worldwide Power Company’s International EV Outlook 2021 notes.

In accordance with that report, registrations of gasoline cell electrical automobiles “stay three orders of magnitude decrease than EVs as hydrogen refuelling stations … should not broadly obtainable and in contrast to EVs can’t be charged at residence.”

The race to dominate the low and 0 emission way forward for Twenty first-century transportation is underway.

On the subject of vehicles, battery electrical automobiles are in a powerful place with corporations resembling Tesla main the cost, however the highway to success isn’t a straight one. Watch this house.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.